December Newsletter

December: Healing through Art and Media

‘Tis the Season to Watch Movies!

Fa La La La La….

Nothing soothes cabin fever better than a good movie, a cozy blanket, and a mug of hot cocoa. When the fear of “wasting a nice day” is eliminated, it can be easier to finally allow ourselves to rest guilt-free. So, put on those comfy pjs, fuzzy socks, and curl up on your couch!


Something we often forget, however, is that the media we consume deeply influences our core beliefs and perceptions. Even if you’re watching the most brainless reality TV, you are still being subliminally influenced by the ways in which relationships are depicted. So, let us ask you this: does your go-to tv show depict relationships in a healthy way, and if not, are you aware of it?

Depictions of Relationships in the Media

Let’s first establish the difference between “healthy” and “unhealthy” relationships.


Relationships exist on a spectrum: healthy, unhealthy, and abusive. If a partner or loved one shows a few unhealthy behaviors, it doesn’t mean your relationship is worth abandoning. We are all human, and have various social influences that can lead us toward these unhealthy tendencies. What is most important is that you and your loved one are willing to address the behaviors in your relationship that are not working.


Healthy relationships allow for respectful and equal interactions, personal freedom, emotional and physical safety, open communication, respected boundaries, and mutual support of goals and desires. People in healthy relationships enjoy their time together, and are also able to enjoy their time apart from one another.


Unhealthy relationships lack communication, trust, and personal autonomy. People in unhealthy relationships can often become co-dependent—ignoring friends, family, and personal hobbies in order to only spend time with their partner.


Abusive relationships occur when personal boundaries are not honored, and one partner is trying to control or harm the other. This can look like: verbal insults, threats, physical harm, financial control, stalking, neglect, accusations, gaslighting, and isolating a partner from their friends and family.


Let us use this framework to analyze the relationships in a few different popular tv shows: Nobody Wants This, Jane the Virgin, Normal People, and Sex and the City.


*P.S. Spoilers Ahead!!!

Will they, won’t they in Nobody Wants This?

What sets Nobody Wants This apart is its portrayal of accountability, vulnerability, and compromise. Noah’s consistent respect and support provide Joanne with the emotional safety to make honest decisions, such as choosing not to convert to Judaism—even though she initially considered it to save the relationship. In turn, Joanne’s confidence and willingness to challenge expectations outside of social norms, inspire Noah to set healthy boundaries with his family, further strengthening their bond.  


In a media landscape often focused on toxic relationships, Nobody Wants This stands out for showcasing a partnership built on trust and growth. This refreshing perspective may be why the series has been renewed for a second season—and why it resonates so strongly with viewers.  

Love Triangles in Jane the Virgin

Though the focus of the show is the love triangle between Jane, Michael, and Rafael, the show is written from an extremely feminist perspective. The show could center solely around Jane’s romantic life, her pregnancy, and her journey as a mother, but her professional and personal goals take just as much precedent. Over the course of the series, not only do her relationships shift and change, but so does her career as a novelist.


Jane’s initial relationship with Michael is depicted in an extremely healthy matter. They are deeply in love, communicative, affectionate, and Michael respects her decision to remain a virgin until marriage. Things get dicey, of course, when Jane develops feelings for Rafael and begins to lose feelings for Michael. Throughout several seasons of changing her mind from one suitor to the other, and even pursuing other relationships, Jane ultimately chooses Rafael in the end.

Class and Power in Normal People

Normal People, based on the novel of the same name by Sally Rooney, features a tumultuous young love between Connell (Paul Mescal) and Marianne (Daisy Edgar-Jones). The show explores the ways in which their long-term on and off again relationship shifts through high school, college, and post-college “adulthood.” To properly analyze the relationship between the two, I think one must look at the power dynamics between them, and how those dynamics shift as they weave in and out of one another’s lives.


Marianne begins her character arc as the unpopular, contemptuous loner. A forceful, intelligent girl with a short temper, seemingly uncaring for what others think of her, but secretly lonely for human connection. Connell, alternatively, is the conventionally handsome, popular athlete who avoids his true identity in order to preserve his curated social image. Marianne comes from an affluent, yet emotionally abusive family, and Connell is raised by his loving, working-class single mother.


The two strike up a secret relationship when Connell’s mother becomes Marianne’s mother’s housekeeper, beginning a strange, unsaid power dynamic. Though one would think that Marianne would be at an advantage in this imbalance of power, Connell wields his social popularity over Marianne by deliberately keeping their relationship secret, ignoring her in public, and ultimately humiliating her. Marianne, already struggling with her self worth, is deeply hurt by this.


Fast forward a few years, and Marianne and Connell both are accepted into the prestigious Trinity College in Dublin. He runs into Marianne, who has now grown into a beautiful, stylish young woman, surrounded by her newfound affluent friends. The power dynamic rapidly shifts, as Marianne, still scorned from her prior heartbreak, is able to wield her class and social status over Connell, who is struggling to even pay for his shared room…

“BIG IS MOVING TO PARIS!” Abusive Relationships in Sex and the City

Many would argue that Big is abusive. He expects Carrie to constantly be at his beck and call, doesn’t communicate with her, lacks emotional intimacy, gaslights her, dates other women behind her back, tells her he isn’t “the marrying type,” and ultimately shows up months later with a fiancée. Clearly, he is as far from Mr. Right as they come.


It is also important to analyze the power dynamic created by Big’s financial situation, as well as his social/political power in New York. Though Carrie and Big hold similar levels of social influence, their financial situations are vastly different. In season four, Mr. Big is able to comfortably give Carrie $30,000 as a down payment on her apartment. This gift, of course, has a catch; it is his tool to get Carrie back into his life and continue his pattern of control.  


After several years of this control, the relationship dynamics grow so unhealthy that Carrie begins to display acts of violence toward Mr. Big. In season two she punches him in the nose, leaving him with a nosebleed and bruise. She has also destroyed his belongings, stalked his ex-wife, and thrown things at him.

DAP Holiday Updates

Closures

DAP will be closed on December 25th in observance of Christmas Day. If you need immediate assistance, the following organizations will be available:


The Hotline

Calls 1-800-799-SAFE (7233)

Text “START” to 88788

Live Chat via the website


Asian Women United of Minnesota
612-724-8823
Domestic violence shelter, support, legal and financial advocacy, 24-hour multilingual help line, employment assistance


Minnesota Day One Crisis Line

Call: 1.866.223.1111

Text: 612.399.9995

Minnesota’s hotline for domestic violence, sexual violence and human trafficking resources and support


Women of Nations

Women in Crisis Hotline: 877-209-1266

Local Crisis Line: 651-251-1609

General inquiries: info@women-of-nations.org

Provides culturally-specific emergency services for Native American communities and support to all who have experienced trauma from domestic violence and sexual assault

Interested in supporting our work? Click the link below.

Next
Next

November 2024 Newsletter